Undermining the HGN Test

| Jan 28, 2019 |

Undermining the HGN TestThe Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus test is one of the three NHTSA-approved field sobriety tests. In almost all DWI cases, the FST results constitute probable cause for the arrest. If the defendant refuses to provide a breath or blood sample, the prosecutor must also use the FST results to establish intoxication beyond a reasonable doubt at trial.

In the HGN test, subjects must follow a moving point, such as the tip of a finger, by using their eyes and not moving their heads.

What is Nystagmus?

Nystagmus is involuntary pupil movements at certain angles. If the defendant’s pupil moves in this way, the person almost always has nystagmus. The two major types of nystagmus are:

· Congenital Nystagmus: Some people can cross their eyes and some people cannot. That’s because some people are born with congenital nystagmus and some are not. This condition is also known as “lazy eye.”

· Acquired Nystagmus: Some people are prone to nystagmus but it never fully develops. Things like alcohol intoxication, diabetes, smoking, flashing lights, and even some excessive vibrations can cause nystagmus.

Nystagmus can be manifest or latent. In a few cases, nystagmus is manifest and it’s apparent at all times. But typically, nystagmus is latent and only evidence when one eyes is covered. So, many people have nystagmus and do not even know it.

HGN Tests in Parker County DWI Cases

The other two FSTs are the walk-and-turn and the one-leg stand. These tests are divided attention tests that measure physical dexterity and mental acuity. But the HGN test is strictly a medical test. Therein lies the problem.

The link between nystagmus and alcohol intoxication is sketchy at best. If a person “fails” the HGN test, it could be because of alcohol intoxication. But most likely, the person had a hitherto unknown congenital eye defect.

HGN tests are about 80 percent accurate if they occur under controlled conditions. But roadside HGN tests are not “controlled conditions.” The sky is dark, squad car overhead lights dance in the background, and car headlights go whizzing by at high speeds. All these factors affect the outcome of the test.

Finally, many officers are poorly trained. They usually attend police-sponsored seminars about how to administer the test, but that is about it. They understand little or nothing about the condition itself. Furthermore, this training seminar might have occurred several years ago, when the research was not current.

The DWI eye test is a poor way to detect intoxication-induced nystagmus. For a free consultation with an experienced criminal defense attorney in Weatherford, contact Herreth Law. We routinely handle cases in Parker County and nearby jurisdictions.